ShineWhere the World Can See You

Generic filters

Who Gets Paid When Music Catalogs Train AI?

When a record label licenses a music catalogue to an artificial-intelligence company, the deal can involve more than copyright in a composition or master recording. It can also implicate the human performances embedded inside that recording. The American Federation of Musicians has made that distinction the center of its new “Human Made, Human Paid” campaign.

Launched on October 23 and followed by an October 29 town hall, the campaign argues that performers need consent, credit and compensation when their recorded work is used in generative-AI systems. The union says licensing negotiations are moving ahead while the terms and revenue flows affecting musicians remain largely undisclosed.

One recording, several layers of rights

A song can contain multiple legal and economic interests: the composition, the master recording, the featured artist’s contract and the contributions of session musicians. A company that controls a catalogue may be able to authorize certain uses without resolving every question of how revenue reaches the people whose performances give the recording its character.

The AFM’s claim is therefore not merely that AI companies should pay for content. It is that payment at the catalogue level does not automatically answer the performer-level questions. The union has not published the terms of the reported label negotiations, and the distribution mechanisms remain a central unresolved issue.

This is an important distinction for visual artists as well. A platform may secure access to an archive, image library or collection while individual creators still need to understand what rights were granted, what uses are covered, and whether attribution or compensation travels with the work.

Consent cannot be inferred from availability

A recording being commercially available does not mean every downstream computational use was contemplated by the performers who made it. Generative systems may ingest, analyze or imitate patterns at a scale and for purposes that were absent from older contracts.

That does not settle the legal questions, which vary by agreement and jurisdiction. It does explain why creators’ organizations are pushing for explicit terms rather than relying on contracts written before current AI systems existed.

The Council of Music Makers has similarly emphasized prior permission, transparency, attribution and a fair share of revenue in its AI guidance. Together, these positions point toward a negotiation framework rather than a blanket technological verdict.

What artists should watch

First, watch who is actually at the table. A deal negotiated by a catalogue owner may not include the representatives of featured artists, session performers, composers or estates. Second, watch the definitions: “training,” “fine-tuning,” “output,” “style imitation” and “digital replica” can carry different obligations.

Third, examine how money is calculated and reported. A one-time catalogue payment, a usage-based royalty and a revenue share produce very different incentives. Without auditable reporting, even a promised share can be difficult to verify.

Finally, separate permission for an input from permission for a synthetic identity. Training on a recording and generating a voice or performance that evokes a particular person are related but not identical acts. Contracts need to say which is contemplated.

The wider creative question

The AFM campaign arrives at a moment when AI licensing is beginning to move from public dispute into private dealmaking. That shift may reduce some uncertainty, but confidentiality can create a new problem if the people represented in the assets cannot see how their work is valued.

For artists across disciplines, the practical lesson is to follow the chain of authority and the chain of payment. Ask who controls the archive, who contributed to it, what the license permits, and how benefits reach the humans whose work makes the system useful.

ATIM approaches artificial intelligence with curiosity, independence, and balance. We explore its extraordinary potential to empower artists while examining the questions it raises around authorship, copyright, consent, creative identity, transparency, and human expression.

We are neither advocates for AI nor opponents of it. Our focus is how the technology is used—and what that means for artists.

Above all, our commitment is to artists. We look at every development through the lens of what can support, protect, and empower the creative community—identifying opportunities, examining potential risks, and providing artists with the information they need to make informed decisions about their work, their rights, and their future.

Spread the Love!

ART + INTELLIGENCE

Introducing ATIM AI

Meet Your AI Creative Guide

by Viviana

We put Viviana's years of guiding artists into an AI made for you — ask it anything, day or night.

Ask it about

how to price and sell your work · protect your rights · approach galleries · grow your audience · understand how AI affects your art or how to stay inspired!

ArtTour International
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x
ArtTour International
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.