A group of creator unions and advocacy organizations has asked a federal court in New York to reject the idea that generative-AI training should receive a broad exemption from copyright law. The filings, submitted at the end of October in the consolidated OpenAI copyright litigation, bring the voices of writers, performers, musicians, photographers, and other rightsholders into a case approaching summary judgment.
The immediate dispute concerns news publishers and OpenAI, but the arguments reach far beyond journalism. At stake is how courts may evaluate the copying of protected work for model training, whether that use is fair, and how alleged market harm should be measured when an AI system can generate or retrieve material that competes for attention with human work.
What the creator groups are asking the court to consider
On October 29, SAG-AFTRA, the American Federation of Musicians, and the Writers Guilds of America East and West announced an amicus brief on behalf of more than 250,000 entertainment and media workers. Their position is that unauthorized use can devalue creative labor and weaken licensing markets that are still developing. A second coalition filing on October 30 included the Human Consent Foundation, Creative Artists Agency, the Music Artists Coalition, the National Association of Voice Actors, and the Creators Coalition on Artificial Intelligence.
The filings do not decide the case. Amicus briefs offer arguments and context from parties who are not the principal litigants, and the court remains responsible for applying copyright law to the facts and evidence before it. OpenAI and Microsoft have contested the publishers’ claims and argue that model training is protected by fair use. Other amici, including Authors Alliance, have urged the court to distinguish infringement from broader claims that model outputs may dilute markets without reproducing protected expression.
That disagreement matters. It places two different questions side by side: whether protected works were copied unlawfully, and whether a new technology changes the economic environment for creators even when a particular output is not substantially similar to a source work.
Why visual artists should pay attention
For visual artists, the case is a reminder that AI disputes are not limited to images that visibly imitate a living artist. They also concern training inputs, documentation, collective licensing, attribution, consent, and the ability to establish a market for authorized uses. A ruling about fair use and market harm in a large consolidated case could influence negotiations well outside news publishing.
Artists do not need to predict the outcome to take practical steps. Preserve dated source files and version histories. Keep licensing terms, commission agreements, and platform notices. Record where high-resolution work is published and whether machine-use preferences were communicated. When joining a licensing program, identify precisely which rights are granted, for what uses, for how long, and whether sublicensing or model training is included.
Collective action is also becoming part of the infrastructure. The new briefs point to unions and rights organizations as possible vehicles for negotiating at scale, but collective systems can only work if they represent creators transparently and account accurately for uses and payments.
A court record, not a final answer
The filings are significant because they put creator consent and licensing markets directly into the summary-judgment record. They are not proof that every training use is infringing, nor do they establish that every AI output harms a market. The decision will turn on evidence, statutory factors, and the court’s analysis of the specific uses at issue.
For artists, the durable lesson is narrower and more useful: document the chain between creation, publication, permission, and payment. As courts test old legal principles against new technical systems, that record is what allows a creator to show not only that a work exists, but how it was offered to the world and on what terms.
ATIM approaches artificial intelligence with curiosity, independence, and balance. We explore its extraordinary potential to empower artists while examining the questions it raises around authorship, copyright, consent, creative identity, transparency, and human expression.
We are neither advocates for AI nor opponents of it. Our focus is how the technology is used—and what that means for artists.
Above all, our commitment is to artists. We look at every development through the lens of what can support, protect, and empower the creative community—identifying opportunities, examining potential risks, and providing artists with the information they need to make informed decisions about their work, their rights, and their future.